Critique Artwork

An art critique is an evaluation of a work of art. While it is true that artistic taste is relative, there are certain characteristics of artwork that can be assessed as a means of measuring the artist's success at conveying the intended message or meaning of the work in question. Art criticism is considered by some to be an art within itself, but, although each art critique may approach a work of art uniquely, there is a defined protocol for the discipline of critiquing a work of art. You do not have to be an art history buff or museum curator to learn how to critique artwork––following defined methods for critiquing will help you to get it right.

Steps

Critiquing

  1. Describe what you see. This is the objective portion of the art critique. It involves a technical description-nothing more. It should include things like:
    • Artist's name
    • Title of work
    • Type of artwork
    • Subject of the painting (scene)
    • Objects in the painting
    • First impression––note the characteristics of the artwork that first jump out at you
    • Colors used
    • Shapes, lines and texture
    • Light saturation
    • Sensory qualities––identify the predominant mood and visual effect.
  2. Analyze the artwork. Evolve the art criticism from a technical description to an in-depth examination of how the technical elements were utilized by the artist to create the overall impression conveyed by the artwork. Technical elements you need to analyze when you critique artwork include:
    • Color.
    • Shapes, forms and lines.
    • Texture.
    • Light and shadow.
    • How each technical element contributes to the mood, meaning and aesthetic sensation of the artwork.
  3. Interpret the artwork. This part of an art critique is more subjective than the others, as you are expected to use your analysis of the technical aspects of the piece of art to apply your own supposition to the artist's intended purpose for the artwork. Try to accomplish the following things when formulating your interpretation:
    • Communicate the artist's statement. Describe what you think the artist is trying to say through the work of art.
    • Expound on the feeling conveyed by the artwork. Describe what the artwork means to you, and why.
    • Explain what you feel is the artist's intended purpose for creating that particular work of art. Examine why the artist made the choices in technique, materials and subject matter and how they relate to the intended purpose.
    • Identify symbols in the artwork and describe how they relate to the artist's technical choices and contribute to the artist's execution of the intended purpose.
  4. Evaluate the artwork. This is a summation of the art criticism process leading up to this point. Use your analysis and interpretation to draw conclusions and reach judgments about the artwork.
    • State what you think the artwork's value is. For example, its value may be to evoke nostalgia, to incite anger or to impart beauty. Explain why you feel this way.
    • Describe the artwork's relevance to the art community and to people as a whole.
    • Explain where you feel the artwork has strong value and where you think it falls short.

Providing an artistic summary

  1. State the history and situation surrounding the artist as they did the piece. This can include the origins of where the piece was found if the artist is unknown.
  2. State the influence the artist was considering while doing the piece.
  3. Describe how their influence/s affected the piece.
  4. State details using a natural flow of statements in an order that readers can follow.
  5. Explain how the details come together through some sort of atmosphere and principles of art in order to symbolize or capture the strongest essence of a/ subject/s.
  6. Summarize the strongest message the piece could be conveying in one decisive statement.
  7. Say how this piece comes across to you:
    • What do you think could be done better?
    • Why didn't the artist do it that way?
    • How is this picture unique in its composition?
    • What have you gained through examining this picture?

Tips

  • Remember, there are no incorrect descriptions when you critique artwork. Your goal is not to say whether or not the art is good, but rather to impart as best you can the visceral response the artwork incites.
  • Use art vocabulary in your art critique.

Related Articles

You may like

Retrieved from "https://kipkis.com/index.php?title=Critique_Artwork&oldid=300206"